Saturday, May 30, 2009

Vetting Political Decisions via a Framework of Liberty

How did Satan become the devil? His final mistake was that he placed a desire to have everyone do what is right above a desire to have them choose for themselves to do what is right. When they all would all be funneled through doing the right thing, he would get all of the glory. (See here for some additional detail, from the LDS book The Pearl of Great Price.)

We often can figure out what is right and wrong; we inherently know, given a sick child who requires a simple $20 medication to get on the road to recovery, that we ought to be personally ready to donate the $20 if we can. But it also really tugs at our heart strings when there are millions of these situations all across the country and we can't solve them all. We are aware of that construct called the government that could seemingly allow us to make sure the problems are rectified, by getting all of our fellow citizens on board to solve the problem together. Surely if everyone donates some, we could cover it, right?

Agency and Liberty

Agency and its sisters liberty and freedom, are among the greatest gifts that we possess as inhabitants of this planet. That we have the ability to choose our actions is perhaps the one attribute that separates us from all other beings. Agency gives us the ability to learn, to experience life, and to mold and direct our experiences. Liberty bequeaths to us personal growth, knowledge, and ultimately the ability to express love, hate, fear, faith, and true charity.

Without agency, we are nothing. There would be no point to our existence, and indeed our very existence simply wouldn't matter. Not to put too fine a point on it, but our agency is a gift that is to be defended to the point of losing our lives, even if we die only in an effort to secure or guard agency for others to exercise. There is no limit to the good that can be done with the gift of agency.

If you will hear it, we all chose agency before we started our mortal existence on our little planet. All of us have cherished it at some point in our lives; even the most insidious murderers and tyrants that have lived thrilled with the discovery that they could control their actions, and produce desired consequences from those actions when they were children. That some of us choose to do evil things with our liberty does not diminish from the goodness and wonder of liberty itself; it only shows the power it engenders.

Liberty carries with it certain conditions. You can choose your actions, but you cannot always choose the consequences of your actions (except by acting or not). If a young girl becomes sexually active, chances are she will eventually end up pregnant. If a boy decides to smoke a cigarette, he may become addicted and have a very hard time breaking the habit later.

Another condition is that we are ultimately responsible for our decisions. Often there are powerful forces that make it very hard to choose alternate actions (sometimes due to our previous choices), but nevertheless we are responsible in great measure for what we choose to do. An obvious corollary of this screams loud and clear:
We ultimately have nobody to blame but ourselves, and the sooner we accept that the sooner we can begin fixing our actions.
We've all heard the excuse, "the devil made me do it." The truth is, Satan lost the battle and he was not given the ability to coerce our every action. He is a powerful influence, but we cannot blame him. We must be prepared to take the bull by the horns, and own up to our actions. We are the masters of our own fate. This understanding allows us to find our own limits, and at what point we must begin to rely on the goodness of others to accomplish what we desire. True liberty engenders humility, and a higher likelihood of people leaning on each other in a sincere and synergistic fashion to accomplish goals for the greater good of society and the individual, without compromising individual liberty. Collectivists should be ashamed of themselves for thinking coercion via government can do better.

Finally, we must note that our agency does affect others. Our right to do something ends when we limit the agency of others where it is not justified. In other words, when we act we must consider carefully the effects that our actions have on others. We are only to act in a way that limits the agency of others when it is strictly justified (and the 'just' part of the word is key): if our neighbor murders someone else, we as a society have the responsibility to enforce consequences on our neighbor, even if that means depriving them of their liberty (as they just did the their victim). But we cannot do so until they commit the crime, and we must only do so commensurately with the crime. There is more to this simplistic view, but nonetheless the principles are true.

Government

Herein lies the great dilemma of every good person on the earth. By passing a law to get everyone to do the right thing (whatever it is we think that may be), is it really the same as if we were to try to educate everyone and convince them via the evidence and proper emotional appeal that it's a good idea? To get them to act of their own free will given the facts? These suffering people need our help, do they not, so is any degree of coercion justified?

I wish to introduce a concept that has made a deep impression on me. I will let a better man than I teach it:
Government is not reason. It is not eloquence. Government is force; like fire it is a dangerous servant -- and a fearful master.
—George Washington, 1797
So, suppose we pass a law that guarantees all the little children are taken care of by everyone contributing a little via a system of taxation. Is it the same as if they chose to help, just as you would spring to help that one little child who needed the $20 medication? The answer is a resounding no. Government is force, and it cannot be thought of rationally in any other terms. It is to be used only when force is truly justified, and the criteria for this should be very restrictive for obvious reasons.

Let's illustrate this in a small microcosm to shed some light on the issue. Suppose we have a child who is very sick, and needs the $20 of medication. You are in the room, your neighbor is in the room, and a police officer (representing the government) is also there. You don't have all $20, but you and your neighbor combined could scrounge up the cash without too much trouble. So you turn to the police officer, and instruct him (with his trusty gun at his side) to go through your wallet and your neighbor's wallet and find $10 each, and go get the medicine for the child. You and your neighbor both are not bankrupted by this, and the child is cured.

There's only one problem. Curing the child by reaching into your neighbor's wallet is theft. If you had stolen money directly from your neighbor to buy the medication with the proclamation, "it is for the greater good!" would that be okay? Note that I didn't state whether the neighbor wanted to volunteer the $10 or not. It doesn't matter. You (and the officer) have violated your neighbor's individual liberty and effectively committed theft against his will to do something seemingly benevolent. You saved a child, isn't that worth it? If you think that is worth it, then at what point do you draw the line?

The line must be drawn as soon as the choice goes beyond your own. If your neighbor murdered the child in cold blood, then the officer should arrest him and he loses his freedom as a direct consequence for doing so. But if the neighbor is otherwise not involved with the child, then he has no requirement to pay the $10. He has a moral obligation to help where he can; but the government cannot and should not enforce that, or else the original motivation (charity and love) is lost.

Consider a few of the unanticipated consequences of forcing people to help others in this manner.
  1. Those who are helped become dependent on the government, and may assume that they will always be helped. They may develop an entitlement problem, and begin to demand the government solve other problems for them at the expense of others. They are less likely to find a way to fix their situation for the long run, because they know that due to the 'benevolence' of the people via the government they'll be taken care of.
  2. Those who are forced to hand over money to the government may then not go out of their way to help anyone individually, even when they can, because they are "doing their part" already as, say, a taxpayer. (Yes, our income taxation system in the US is definitely forced because if you don't pay, armed officers eventually arrest you and you face still penalties and/or prison time.)
  3. The helper and the helped become disconnected, and people over time lose a sense of what it means to help, who they are helping, and whether what they are doing is helping at all. Those who are helped lose a sense of gratitude, and in fact begin to view the nameless masses helping them as if they are not hurt at all by any of this.
Negative knock-on effects from government intervention always show up in the long term, especially when it boils down to a question of agency.

How to Save the World

We all have an innate desire to provide relief from pain and suffering. There is nothing wrong with this desire; in fact, it is definitely a good quality to nurture. But how we choose to do the helping is a seminal question. The right question to ask is not just, "how do we save the world?" but rather, "how do we save the world, the right way?"

Think of the US invasion of Iraq in the 2003-2010 time frame. The US invaded, toppled the government, and established a regime that is based on democratic elections and a constitution (the latter being the more important aspect, but that's a discussion for later). Our soldiers fought insurgents and others, being told and believing that they were giving freedom to the Iraqi people. Those soldiers had the best of intentions, and their hearts were not in the wrong place. However, was it right for the leaders of the US to invade Iraq, even if the only purpose was to give the Iraqi people freedom (which it certainly was not)?

You guessed it: given the principles of agency the answer is no. You cannot force liberty on other people, just like you can't force them to do good things and expect the outcome to be the same as if they chose good willingly. If all of the Iraqi people rose up in rebellion against Saddam Hussein to establish liberty, they would have won. However, if they weren't willing to fight for it themselves then we have no business forcing it on them. Forced liberty is no liberty at all. Again, a quote from the founding fathers is appropriate. The whole speech is longer, so please digest it in its entirety:

Wherever the standard of freedom and Independence has been or shall be unfurled, there will her [America's] heart, her benedictions and her prayers be.

But she goes not abroad, in search of monsters to destroy.

She is the well-wisher to the freedom and independence of all.

She is the champion and vindicator only of her own.

She will commend the general cause by the countenance of her voice, and the benignant sympathy of her example.

--John Quincy Adams, July 4 1821

You very well could have the word 'she' above be replaced with 'liberty' and it would still fit perfectly because America and liberty should be synonymous. We should provide a good example, provide a convincing argument, and preach (yes, preach) liberty to all nations with a clear, unmistakable voice. We should be friends with all who will let us. But we should never coerce, we should not preemptively punish those who oppose even liberty, and we should not force our worldview on others, without violating even the core principle of liberty itself. Defending liberty means we fight for our own liberty and the liberty of anyone else who also fights for it. But those who do not value it enough to fight or work to secure it for themselves do not deserve it until they muster the desire to defend it to the death, as many of us have.

Now you know the way to save the world the right way. It is to be a good example, to be friends with all, to educate and persuade all that liberty and agency are worth living and dying for. It is to donate your own $20 to the child in need, and encourage your neighbor to do the same through all non-coercive means; but it never means to compel. It is to not shield others from the negative consequences of their actions, and it is to insist that people take as much responsibility for their actions as possible. It is to realize and teach others that liberty must be cared for and guarded vigilantly. It is to understand that our actions affect others and that our right to act unilaterally stops the moment we seriously affect the liberty of others. Saving the world even requires that we defend to the death the right of our neighbor to disagree with us, and the right of our neighbor to keep his money from that child who is sick and needs it.

It is heart-wrenching to know that some people do not choose the good with their liberty, but it is the very essence of humanity that allows us to choose the good, and along with it to be able to choose evil.

To force anyone to choose good is to destroy it. I, for one, will choose liberty even if it means that I die trying.

Monday, May 4, 2009

A Family Update

I have failed miserably at my New Year's resolution to update this blog weekly. Ah, well, with moving and being a mom and not sleeping I guess I can't blame myself.

Our family is settling in to the house we moved into. It's a month to month lease so we really don't know how long we are going to stay so we still have a lot of boxes that will stay sealed. We hope that we will be able to buy a house relatively soon, but we have to save some more money.

Miriam has enjoyed having a yard and a playground in the back. Isaac likes having plenty of space to crawl and practicing walking. Both Miriam and Isaac get into everything, which makes it very difficult for me to keep things clean or organized.

One thing I have enjoyed lately is having a double jogging stroller and a nice long walking path close by. I take the kids for a jog several times a week and I get some fresh air and exercise. Mike has been trying to get me to go to a Krav Maga class with him for some exercise. I would love to, but that means finding a babysitter. Maybe I can get the Bishop's daughter to babysit for me this summer.

Mike is always busy at work. He really likes his job and we're really glad that he has a job. I still can't convince myself to like the Bay Area. Maybe if/when the economy recovers Mike will be able to find a job in an area I actually like.

Next week is Isaac's first birthday. It's hard to believe how fast kids grow. Isaac is walking and babbling. Miriam is learning her numbers, letters, colors, etc. Hopefully I can get some more pictures and videos up. Miriam says the funniest things and Isaac is just so active.

Saturday, March 14, 2009

Ron Paul Revolution

I'll write sometime soon why I like Ron Paul more and more all the time. I didn't "discover" him until after the 2008 election primaries, and I'm kicking myself for not having done so sooner.

Here are a few videos to get you started learning what kind of a guy he is. If you are curious, follow the banner on the side to the Campaign for Liberty where there is a lot more.







Sunday, February 22, 2009

Rain, rain and potty training

It's been raining a lot lately here in the Bay Area the past week. It's been raining all day today. I really like the rain and if I didn't have kids I would probably be out dancing in the rain. Miriam might like dancing in the rain, but Isaac would scream bloody murder.

I figured that rain would prevent me from taking Miriam outside much I would try to do something productive with her indoors. . . . . potty training. I helped to potty train an autistic preschooler when I was in college so I figured this would be a snap. Miriam has actually done pretty well, but I think all the books that claim you can potty train your child in just one day are full of it. Miriam has no problem going "pee pee" in the potty, especially since she gets M&Ms when she goes. She just doesn't always tell me when she needs to go. Good thing Huggies invented pull-ups.

Today we had regional conference. It was broadcast to our building. There were a lot of good messages. One that stuck out in my mind (probably because it was "meant" for me) was what Elder Wickman said about living in California. He talked about how bad things have happened or are happening here in California, but that doesn't mean the saints should just pick up and leave. That seemed to be the theme of the conference. Building Zion where one is. My husband had to kind of poke me about this. I reminded him that living somewhere and trying to make the most of it doesn't mean I have to like the place I'm living.

I have to be honest, California has some really cool places to visit. Key word here: VISIT. I really don't like a lot of aspects of living here. I don't want to raise my family in the Bay Area. I've heard a lot of people talk about how wonderful San Francisco is. I've visited San Fran twice. It's a pretty city and a good place to visit. What most people don't understand is that San Francisco isn't all of the Bay Area. There are a lot of nice places to live here, but they are really expensive and most of the schools here are gang infested so even if we were to find a nice place to live the chances of us being near really good schools is slim.

I've realized how lucky I was to grow up in Centerville. I know that Utah has it's issues, but when I was growing up Utah was a really nice place. People here in California have such low standards sometimes. I thought that maybe I was really picky when it came to housing, schools, quality service, etc. I think it's more that I grew up in an area where people took care of their houses, I had good teachers in public schools, and most of the people I interacted with when it came to service were pretty happy, which is defnitely not the case here.

This week I need to start de-junking my house. We will be moving in about a month and I'm determined to only box up and take what we use, will use, and have used in the past 2 years. It's too bad any time I start de-junking things Miriam finds some object to get attached to. Two-year-olds are so funny sometimes.

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Bailouts: Recursive Loop Spending

This post is inspired by a challenge from Stewart Feil, who gave me simply the title and wanted to see what I would write when I looked at it.

Bailouts are more like the inadvertent governmental way of cornering markets, making the government the 'only' market for something. This happens because once the government starts buying something (shares in a company above price, long end of the treasury curve, etc.), everyone will essentially hold out to sell to the government, so as to get the "screw the taxpayer" price. Bailouts also have the effect on the receivers of holding risky behavior in esteem, and the effect on the rest of the market of increasing mistrust.

One bailout begets another; or, at least it does if you don't realize your philosophy completely sucks, and that you can't out-maneuver mathematics. It softens, widens and deepens the collapse of debt default into a down-trending, see-saw shape. The default has to happen to relieve the exponential growth in debt, but bailouts distort and prolong the process. They introduce mistrust in the market environment, destroying the meaning of prices. Many groups (from the porn industry, to autos, to homebuilders, to banks) demand a bailout, and everyone else waits to buy because they don't know who is going to get favored next. Bailouts ultimately drag out the eventual re-establishment of a solid bottom, which is necessary for true, proper linear economic growth from real production.

The other problem with bailouts is that, to be blunt, it's like trying to treat a burn victim with a blowtorch. We have a huge debt problem. Debt is defaulting, causing total money/credit to contract (read: deflation) back to sustainable levels. This *must* happen, because banks and the Fed serially blew bubbles in the market to just kick the can down the road, and the can was getting bigger, and bigger. Bailouts of necessity require an increase in debt or a decrease in savings, which is precisely the problem that got us here in the first place. And, once you have a few patrons addicted to debt, they don't get broken of the habit without some really bad hangovers, and have to fall on their face a few times before they realize you are serious about cutting them loose. This is as true of corporations as it is of individual people. The longer you go giving out bailouts, the harder it will be to cut off the freeloaders later, and so it goes until your hand is forced. In the meantime, you will have done yourself likely serious harm in terms of solvency. There is no "right amount" of capital to give out that will turn a recession around; companies, and people, are black holes when it comes to money. Those who manage it well don't need bailouts, even when they are bankrupt, and those who don't will never manage it well even if they get bailed out. What's even worse, is the government is bailing firms out with *our* money, not theirs. See the following for a funny, but accurate depiction of what is going on:

http://patrick.net/housing/contrib/Fannie.jpg


Recursive bailouts are predicated on the people who have the power to give the money out either ignoring, or not understanding these simple truths. The average person, and thus the average company, is not so unlike a homeless guy that you give $4 million. Generally speaking, he'll blow it in no time and not be better off in the long run. If you think that means you just didn't give him enough, then you are throwing good money after bad and are a complete fool.

The parallels to what our government is doing are quite obvious.

Sunday, February 8, 2009

Sick of sickness

This week our whole family has had to deal with sickness. First Miriam came down with a cold, then I got it, then Isaac, and yesterday Mike succumb to the nasty virus. Being home sick with two sick kids has been a pain. I barely get enough sleep as it is and then to be getting up in the night made it really hard. Poor Mike has had to deal with a very grumpy wife.

I usually don't let Miriam watch much TV, but this past week we probably watched The Little Mermaid and Curious George like 3 times each. I'm hoping the weather is good this week so we can get out and about. I'm really sick of being inside for days at a time. I was glad to go to church today with Miriam because that meant I got to leave the house! :)

Since we've been sick this week we haven't done anything really interesting. Valentine's Day is coming up and so is my birthday. We'll see if Mike remembers to get me anything for either of those days.

Maybe I'll have something interesting to write later this week. I'm posting a little video clip of Miriam and Isaac having fun despite being sick.

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

States' Rights

Over the last 100 years or so, we have seen a steady slide away from Constitutional principles in the United States toward a huge, bloated, powerful central government. I need to write up a post some day on the government's handling (and complicity) in the Great Depression as an example of what groundwork was laid, but suffice it to say most government programs and legislation we have these days have no basis in the US Constitution whatsoever.

But, we have some legislators that are starting to get brave. This is a wonderful sign that the pressure buildup is finally starting to make people motivated. Consider this house resolution in New Hampshire, to be voted on in a couple of days in committee:

New Hampshire to Vote on putting the federal government in its place

Please, please read this in its entirety. It is a wonder to behold. I really, really hope this is passed, and that other states follow suit as soon as possible. Here is a small snippet to get your toes wet with excitement:
That the Constitution of the United States, having delegated to Congress a power to punish treason, counterfeiting the securities and current coin of the United States, piracies, and felonies committed on the high seas, and offences against the law of nations, slavery, and no other crimes whatsoever; and it being true as a general principle, and one of the amendments to the Constitution having also declared, that “the powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people,” therefore all acts of Congress which assume to create, define, or punish crimes, other than those so enumerated in the Constitution are altogether void, and of no force; and that the power to create, define, and punish such other crimes is reserved, and, of right, appertains solely and exclusively to the respective States, each within its own territory...
And another:

That any Act by the Congress of the United States, Executive Order of the President of the United States of America or Judicial Order by the Judicatories of the United States of America which assumes a power not delegated to the government of United States of America by the Constitution for the United States of America and which serves to diminish the liberty of the any of the several States or their citizens shall constitute a nullification of the Constitution for the United States of America by the government of the United States of America. Acts which would cause such a nullification include, but are not limited to:

I. Establishing martial law or a state of emergency within one of the States comprising the United States of America without the consent of the legislature of that State.

II. Requiring involuntary servitude, or governmental service other than a draft during a declared war, or pursuant to, or as an alternative to, incarceration after due process of law.

III. Requiring involuntary servitude or governmental service of persons under the age of 18 other than pursuant to, or as an alternative to, incarceration after due process of law.

IV. Surrendering any power delegated or not delegated to any corporation or foreign government.

V. Any act regarding religion; further limitations on freedom of political speech; or further limitations on freedom of the press.

VI. Further infringements on the right to keep and bear arms including prohibitions of type or quantity of arms or ammunition
A return to smaller, Constitutional government and less meddling in our markets would restore confidence, freedom, reduce debt, relieve the tax burden on individuals and businesses, and probably pull us out of our current recession (or, should I say, depression?) very quickly. More on that later. But the above resolution is rather self-explanatory, and stands on its own two feet. It takes a bold stance, even talking about nullification of the federal government if they overstep their bounds again. I think the last time our country talked about nullification was before the Civil War.

Update: Arizona seems to be following suit.

Update 2: Oklahoma has also already done this, despite a media blackout.

Update 3: And, at least one more brewing. This one is from Missouri, and is more limited, stating Constitutional limits urging the federal government to reject FOCA legislation (and FOCA is a horrid bill). There are also rumblings of similar happenings in Montana, and news from the last decade of Kansas and Texas making similar declarations.

Update 4: Now they're rolling in! Washington State is joining the fray, as is Montana, and Michigan (see House concurrent resolution 4).